Entries for March 2014

The previous post started to discuss the inconsistency that collectivists have regarding the use of redistributed wealth by those who receive it – that it will be used for its intended purpose.  One of the main arguments for government forced redistribution is that people who have wealth will not do the right things with it.  On the other hand, collectivists assume that those who receive the redistributions will do the right things with them, or at least will be better stewards of what they receive than those from whom it came.  Why else would a redistribution be warranted unless it were to be used for some greater good?  Otherwise a redistribution is simply legalized theft.  The assertion underlying wealth redistributions implies that virtue among those receiving the redistribution is greater than those whose wealth is redistributed.  During the Middle Ages, the general view was that those who accumulated wealth possessed greater virtues related to physical things (stewardship, frugality, etc.), while those who were poor possessed greater spiritual virtues (piety, humility, etc.).  It was not thought that one group’s virtue was greater than the other; but rather that the virtues they possessed were merely different – neither was better than the other.

Read More

Posted in: Stewardship

There is a relationship between the other two points from the previous post:  those around the government’s role in achieving a fair distribution of society’s wealth, and whether people will do the rights things with the redistributed wealth they receive.  At the heart of this matter is the answer to the following question, ‘Who is best able to direct society’s resources, its individuals or its government?’ – for its answer is directly connected to charity.  Historically, until somewhat recently, charity has consisted of providing things such as bread, food, shelter, care for those unable to care for themselves (widows, orphans, aged, and the dying), and debt relief.  Charity is about service and providing sacrificially, simply because another is in need, and throughout the Middle Ages there was a direct connection between the giver and the receiver.

Read More

Posted in: Stewardship
Search My Blog
About Dan Wolf

Dan WolfMy goal is that my writing will help you to get started on your own journey of discovery, or help you along the way on a journey you may have already begun. Our Founders considered education, religion, morality, and virtue to be the cornerstones for any successful society. Being successful requires understanding both the languages of reason and faith; reason alone is insufficient.